Home/Case Law/JAQUELINE GARCIA vs. AMAZON.COM, INC.; LIBERTY MUTUAL
Regular DecisionPetition for Reconsideration

JAQUELINE GARCIA vs. AMAZON.COM, INC.; LIBERTY MUTUAL

Filed: Sep 23, 2025
San Bernadino
ADJ18961005

CompFox AI Summary

Applicant Jaqueline Garcia petitioned for reconsideration after a Workers' Compensation Administrative Law Judge (WCJ) determined she was an independent contractor, not an employee of Amazon.com, Inc., when she sustained injuries. The Appeals Board granted the petition, citing concerns over the WCJ's application of the burden of proof regarding employment status and the evidential weight given to the 'Amazon Flex Independent Contractor Terms of Service' document. The Board emphasized that the record did not clearly establish if the applicant met her initial burden or if the defendant successfully rebutted the employment presumption under applicable codes. Consequently, a final decision on the merits of the reconsideration is deferred to allow for further review of the factual and legal issues.

JAQUELINE GARCIA vs. AMAZON.COM, INC.; LIBERTY MUTUAL is a workers' compensation case decided in San Bernadino. This case addresses legal issues related to compensation claims, benefits, and court rulings.

It is commonly referenced in legal research involving workers' compensation laws in San Bernadino.

Full Decision Text1 Pages

Applicant Jaqueline Garcia petitioned for reconsideration after a Workers' Compensation Administrative Law Judge (WCJ) determined she was an independent contractor, not an employee of Amazon.com, Inc., when she sustained injuries. The Appeals Board granted the petition, citing concerns over the WCJ's application of the burden of proof regarding employment status and the evidential weight given to the 'Amazon Flex Independent Contractor Terms of Service' document. The Board emphasized that the record did not clearly establish if the applicant met her initial burden or if the defendant successfully rebutted the employment presumption under applicable codes. Consequently, a final decision on the merits of the reconsideration is deferred to allow for further review of the factual and legal issues.

Read the full decision

Join + legal professionals. Create a free account to access the complete text of this decision and search our entire database.

JAQUELINE GARCIA vs. AMAZON.COM, INC.; LIBERTY MUTUAL workers compensation case in San Bernadino. Legal case summary, ruling, and analysis for attorneys and legal research.

JAQUELINE GARCIA vs. AMAZON.COM, INC.; LIBERTY MUTUAL case law summary from San Bernadino. Workers compensation legal decision, case analysis, and court ruling details.

JAQUELINE GARCIA vs. AMAZON.COM, INC.; LIBERTY MUTUAL Case Analysis

JAQUELINE GARCIA vs. AMAZON.COM, INC.; LIBERTY MUTUAL is a legal case related to workers' compensation in San Bernadino. This case explains important rulings, legal interpretations, and claim decisions.

Ready to streamline your practice?

Apply these legal strategies instantly. CompFox helps you find decisions, analyze reports, and draft pleadings in minutes.