Case Law Database

BYRON MATTAS vs. SHOKER TRADING CORPORATION dba TRIPLE S. CHEVRON, HANOVER INSURANCE COMPANY

This case concerns a workers' compensation claim where the applicant sustained injuries during an altercation with a customer. The defendant argued the claim was barred by specific Labor Code sections, including being the initial physical aggressor. The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) dismissed the defendant's petition for removal and denied reconsideration, upholding the judge's finding that the applicant was not the initial aggressor, based largely on surveillance video. A dissenting commissioner argued that the applicant was indeed the initial physical aggressor by throwing soup, thus barring the claim.