Case Law Database

Kevin Voelker vs. D. Frey Plastering Co., State Compensation Insurance Fund

This case involves a workers' compensation applicant challenging an Independent Medical Review (IMR) determination that denied authorization for shoulder surgery. The applicant argued the IMR incorrectly applied guidelines for acromioplasty/impingement syndrome instead of guidelines for a rotator cuff tear, which was the actual condition for which surgery was requested. The Appeals Board granted reconsideration, finding the IMR's determination was based on a plainly erroneous mistake of fact readily apparent from the submitted records, not requiring expert opinion. Consequently, the Board rescinded the IMR determination and remanded the matter for a new IMR process.