Federal Insurance v. North American Specialty Insurance
This case involves Federal Insurance Company suing Rivkin Radler LLP, Bruce A. Bendix, and Allied World Assurance Company (U.S.), Inc. for legal malpractice, bad faith, and indemnity. Federal, as an excess liability insurer and subrogee of Galaxy General Contracting Corp., sought to recoup $2,000,000 it paid to settle an underlying personal injury action. The core issue revolves around the defendants' failure to assert the antisubrogation rule, which Federal argued would have limited CUIC's (Galaxy's primary insurer) liability. The Appellate Division reversed the Supreme Court's denial of Rivkin's motion to dismiss Federal's claims, finding no privity for Federal's direct malpractice claim and no actual damages sustained by Galaxy for the subrogation claims. The court affirmed the bad faith claim against CUIC regarding the second cause of action but dismissed the first and third causes of action.