Chavarria v. Bruce Nagel & Partners Architects, P.C.
Jose Chavarria, an employee, sustained personal injuries on a renovation project and initiated an action against Bruce Nagel & Partners Architects, P.C. (Nagel, P.C.) and David L. Wasserman and Ellen F. Wasserman (the Wassermans). Nagel, P.C. had a contract with the Wassermans for architectural services, which included a provision requiring the Wassermans to ensure Nagel, P.C. was an additional insured on the general contractor's liability policy, regardless of whether construction administration services were regular or ad hoc. Despite an addendum modifying the frequency of services, the insurance requirement remained. Following Chavarria's injury, Nagel, P.C. moved for summary judgment to dismiss Chavarria's complaint and on its cross-claim for breach of contract against the Wassermans. The Appellate Division, Second Department, reversed the Supreme Court's order, granting Nagel, P.C.'s motion for summary judgment, thereby dismissing the complaint against Nagel, P.C. and finding the Wassermans liable for breach of contract.