CompFox Logo
AboutWorkflowFeaturesPricingCase LawInsights

Updated Daily

Case Law Database

Access over workers' compensation decisions, including En Banc, Significant Panel Decisions, and writ-denied cases.

Case No. ADJ7828286
Regular
Oct 09, 2013

REGINALD GERMANY vs. BUFFALO BILLS, TRAVELERS INSURANCE COMPANY

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) granted reconsideration, rescinding the prior decision that California lacked jurisdiction over the applicant's cumulative trauma injury claim. The WCAB found that the prior judge improperly applied personal jurisdiction principles. The case is returned for further proceedings to determine if defendants are exempt from WCAB jurisdiction under Labor Code section 3600.5(b) or if jurisdiction should be declined based on a mandatory forum selection clause and limited connection to California, as established in relevant en banc decisions.

Workers' Compensation Appeals BoardCumulative Trauma InjuryJurisdictionProfessional Football PlayerMcKinley v. Arizona CardinalsLabor Code Section 3600.5(b)Carroll v. Cincinnati BrownsForum Selection ClauseLimited Connection to CaliforniaExtraterritorial Provisions
References
Case No. ADJ11706407
Regular
Apr 15, 2025

Matthew Hatchette vs. Oakland Raiders, TIG/Fairmont Premier Insurance Company, Jacksonville Jaguars, ACE American Insurance Company, New York Jets, USF&G, Chubb, Pacific Employers Insurance

This case concerns Matthew Hatchette, a former professional football player, and his claims of continuous trauma injuries against multiple NFL teams and their insurers. Defendant Jacksonville Jaguars filed a Petition for Reconsideration challenging the Workers' Compensation Administrative Law Judge's (WCJ) findings regarding jurisdiction and the applicability of res judicata. The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) granted the petition to conduct a thorough review of the factual and legal issues, thereby deferring a final decision on the merits. The Board's decision also addressed the timeliness of the petition under the recently amended Labor Code section 5909.

Workers' Compensation Appeals BoardMatthew HatchetteOakland RaidersJacksonville JaguarsNew York JetsTIG/Fairmont Premier Insurance CompanyChubbUSF&GGallagher Bassett ServicesZenith Insurance Company
References
Case No. ADJ8501790
Regular
Jul 29, 2015

Kelly Chase vs. St. Louis Blues Hockey Club, Federal Insurance Company

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) reversed a prior finding of industrial injury for a professional hockey player against the St. Louis Blues. The WCAB found insufficient connection to California for jurisdiction, citing the player's limited games in the state compared to his overall career. This decision followed the precedent set in *Federal Insurance Co. v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Johnson)*, which requires a legitimate and substantial connection to the state for jurisdiction. The WCAB concluded that 21 games out of 485 did not meet this standard for a cumulative injury claim.

WCABSt. Louis Blues Hockey ClubFederal Insurance CompanyADJ8501790Opinion and Decision After Reconsiderationcumulative industrial injuryprofessional hockey playersubject matter jurisdictionstatute of limitationssubstantial medical evidence
References
Case No. SRO 0116034
Regular
Jul 05, 2007

ELENORA ROBINSON vs. RAPISTAN SYSTEMS, FIREMAN'S FUND

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board denied the applicant's petition for reconsideration of an order vacating a trial date. This denial was based on the principle that a final adjudication of the applicant's Labor Code section 132a claim had already occurred and all subsequent appeals were exhausted. Furthermore, the Board found it lacked jurisdiction to reopen a section 132a claim due to statutory time limitations, as the petition to reopen was filed more than five years after the date of injury.

Labor Code section 132aPetition to ReopenOrder Vacating Trial DateWorkers' Compensation Appeals Boardfinal adjudicationjurisdictionarbitrarycapriciousPetition for Reconsiderationres judicata
References
Case No. ADJ3138312 (WCK 0059967)
Regular
Jul 05, 2011

GREGORY McBEE vs. AMERICAN DESIGN ROOFING, CIGA, LEGION INSURANCE COMPANY

The Appeals Board rescinded a prior award of temporary disability benefits because the applicant's period of temporary disability commenced more than five years after his date of injury. The Board found that Labor Code section 5410, which allows for claims of new and further disability within five years of injury, did not apply here. Jurisdiction to award temporary disability beyond five years is limited to continuous disability that began within that timeframe, which was not established. The case was returned for further proceedings on the issue of permanent disability.

Petition to reopennew and further disabilitytemporary disability indemnityjurisdictionfive-year limitationdate of injurystipulated awardAgreed Medical Evaluatorwrit deniedsubstantial medical evidence
References
Case No. ADJ13302605; ADJ15813943
Regular
Mar 07, 2023

MATTHEW WARE vs. ARIZONA CARDINALS FOOTBALL CLUB, LLC, GREAT DIVIDE INSURANCE COMPANY C/O BERKLEY ENTERTAINMENT

The Workers' Compensation Appeals Board granted the defendant's Petition for Removal, reversing the WCJ's order to set the case for a Mandatory Settlement Conference on all issues. The Board found good cause to bifurcate and try the threshold issues of California subject matter and personal jurisdiction first. Bifurcating these jurisdictional issues is deemed more efficient, as a favorable ruling for the defendant would avoid further litigation. This decision prioritizes an expedited resolution of jurisdiction to facilitate the prompt delivery of potential benefits.

Petition for RemovalMandatory Settlement ConferenceBifurcationJurisdictionSubject Matter JurisdictionPersonal JurisdictionSpecial AppearanceDeclaration of ReadinessDiscoveryGood Cause
References
Case No. ADJ7460656
En Banc
Jan 15, 2013

DENNIS MCKINLEY vs. ARIZONA CARDINALS, THE TRAVELERS INDEMNITY COMPANY

The Appeals Board affirmed the WCJ's decision, declining to exercise jurisdiction over a cumulative injury claim due to a reasonable mandatory forum selection clause in the employment contract specifying Arizona as the forum, coupled with the applicant's limited connection to California.

WORKERS' COMPENSATION APPEALS BOARDEN BANCCUMULATIVE INJURYPROFESSIONAL FOOTBALL PLAYERARIZONA CARDINALSTRAVELERS INDEMNITY COMPANYFORUM SELECTION CLAUSEMANDATORY FORUMLIMITED CONNECTIONEMPLOYMENT CONTRACT
References
Case No. OAK 0274341
Regular
Sep 24, 2007

DAVID LAUDENBACH vs. CENTRAL WHOLESALE ELECTRIC SUPPLIES

The Appeals Board denied the defendant's petition challenging the WCJ's jurisdiction to award temporary disability benefits, finding that jurisdiction was not lost as the issue was deferred and the case remained open. The Board granted the applicant's petition, amending the award to defer the issue of temporary disability for a later period (January 19, 2005, through March 29, 2006) because a stipulated permanent and stationary date does not preclude a subsequent period of temporary disability. The matter was returned to the trial level for further proceedings to determine eligibility for this later period of temporary disability.

WCABPetition for ReconsiderationFindings and Awardtemporary disability benefitsstatute of limitationspermanent and stationary dateres judicataEmployment Development Department (EDD) lienstipulationjurisdiction
References
Case No. ADJ3045197 (LAO 0818234)
Regular
Oct 07, 2011

DIOMEDES QUINONEZ vs. CHECKMATE STAFFING, INC., BUCKEYE CLAIMS, J.C. PENNEY, INC., AIG CLAIM SERVICES, UNINSURED EMPLOYERS BENEFITS TRUST FUND

The Uninsured Employers Benefits Trust Fund (UEF) sought reconsideration of a prior award against Checkmate Staffing, arguing an automatic bankruptcy stay invalidated it. The Board denied the UEF's petition, finding it lacked jurisdiction to rescind an award over seven years old. California Labor Code Section 5804 strictly limits rescission or alteration of awards to five years post-injury. The Board emphasized that rescinding the award would contravene the legislative intent behind the UEF to protect workers injured by illegally uninsured employers.

Uninsured Employers Benefits Trust FundPetition for ReconsiderationFindings and AwardBankruptcy Automatic StayLabor Code Section 5804Jurisdictional LimitationRescind AwardContinuing JurisdictionLegally Uninsured EmployerDate of Injury
References
Case No. ADJ 8937991
Regular
May 23, 2017

ANTONIO PIERCE vs. WASHINGTON REDSKINS, ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE AND TRAVELERS, NEW YORK FOOTBALL GIANTS, INC., GREAT DIVIDE INSURANCE COMPANY

This case concerns whether the California Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) has jurisdiction over a professional football player's cumulative injury claim. The applicant asserts he was hired in California by the Washington Redskins and New York Football Giants, Inc., triggering WCAB jurisdiction. Defendants argued against jurisdiction, citing limited California contacts and employment contracts specifying other state laws. The WCAB affirmed the judge's finding of jurisdiction, holding that the applicant's hiring in California is sufficient to establish subject matter jurisdiction under Labor Code sections 3600.5 and 5305, irrespective of other contacts.

Workers' Compensation Appeals BoardAntonio PierceWashington RedskinsACE American InsuranceTravelersNew York Football GiantsGreat Divide Insurance Companyjurisdictioncontract of hireFederal Insurance Co. v. Workers' Comp. Appeals Bd. (Johnson)
References
Showing 1-10 of 2,742 results

Ready to streamline your practice?

Apply these legal strategies instantly. CompFox helps you find decisions, analyze reports, and draft pleadings in minutes.

CompFox Logo

The AI standard for workers' compensation professionals. Faster research, deeper analysis, better outcomes.

Product

  • Platform
  • Workflow
  • Features
  • Pricing

Solutions

  • Defense Firms
  • Applicants' Attorneys
  • Insurance carriers
  • Medical Providers

Company

  • About
  • Insights
  • Case Law

Legal

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Trust
  • Cookies
  • Subscription

© 2026 CompFox Inc. All rights reserved.

Systems Operational