CompFox Logo
AboutWorkflowFeaturesPricingCase LawInsights

Updated Daily

Case Law Database

Access over workers' compensation decisions, including En Banc, Significant Panel Decisions, and writ-denied cases.

Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Phillips v. Old Republic Insurance Co.

This opinion addresses multiple cases where employees were awarded total permanent disability benefits for coal workers' pneumoconiosis. The primary issue concerns the calculation of the weekly benefit rate pursuant to T.C.A. § 50-1105. Specifically, the employer challenged the application of a fifty percent increase in benefits for employees with one dependent, arguing it conflicted with federal maximum compensation limits. The court affirmed the trial court's calculation, emphasizing that while state rates had surpassed federal maximums, the statutes must be applied as written, including the dependency increase.

Workers' CompensationCoal Workers' PneumoconiosisBlack Lung DiseaseDisability BenefitsBenefit Rate CalculationStatutory InterpretationTennessee LawFederal Coal Mine Health and Safety ActDependent BenefitsPermanent Total Disability
References
3
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Bridges v. Liberty Insurance Co. of Hartford

The Special Workers’ Compensation Appeals Panel reviewed Stanley Bridges's motion concerning his workers’ compensation claim. Bridges, a former coal miner, was diagnosed with pneumoconiosis and rheumatoid arthritis. Medical evaluations indicated his total disability stemmed primarily from rheumatoid arthritis, not his pulmonary condition. The chancellor initially awarded permanent partial disability for pneumoconiosis, but the Appeals Panel reversed this, stating that under Tennessee law, coal worker's pneumoconiosis requires total disability for benefits, and no other compensable occupational disease was established. Consequently, the motion for review was denied, and the claim was dismissed.

Workers' CompensationPneumoconiosisOccupational DiseaseTotal DisabilityPermanent Partial DisabilityRheumatoid ArthritisMedical EvaluationB Reader CertificationFederal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969Black Lung Benefits Act
References
9
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Jeffers v. Sterling Garrett Coal Co.

The case involves an appeal by a plaintiff, Mr. Jeffers, whose claim for permanent total disability due to coal worker’s pneumoconiosis was denied by the trial court. The appellate court reviewed whether the trial court applied the correct legal standards, specifically those mandated by T.C.A., § 50-1102 which incorporates federal regulations. While medical experts for the plaintiff diagnosed pneumoconiosis and disability, the defendant's expert attributed the major cause of the plaintiff's pulmonary impairment to cigarette smoking and emphysema. The court affirmed the trial court's dismissal, finding material evidence supported the conclusion that the plaintiff's respiratory impairment did not primarily arise from employment in a coal mine, thereby rebutting the statutory presumption of disability due to pneumoconiosis.

PneumoconiosisCoal Miner DisabilityWorkmen's CompensationOccupational DiseaseTotal DisabilityFederal Coal Mine Health and Safety ActRebuttable PresumptionMedical EvidenceEmphysemaCigarette Smoking
References
7
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Bituminous Casualty Corp. v. Lewis

This workmen's compensation case concerns an appellee who was awarded permanent total disability benefits for pneumoconiosis, an occupational disease. The appellant, Bituminous Casualty Corporation, disputed the award, arguing a lack of evidence for employment-caused disease, improper notice, and statutory limitations. The court examined relevant Tennessee Code Annotated sections regarding employer liability and the timeliness of claims for coal worker's pneumoconiosis. It affirmed the chancellor's finding that the appellee was last injuriously exposed at Kopper Glo Fuels, Inc., and filed the claim within the three-year statutory period applicable from the discovery of disability on December 20, 1972.

workmen's compensationoccupational diseasepneumoconiosiscoal miningstatutory interpretationnotice requirementslimitation of actionspermanent total disabilityemployer liabilityTennessee law
References
4
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Lively v. Consolidation Coal Co.

Robert M. Lively, a 50-year-old coal miner, developed silicosis or pneumoconiosis after 31 years of working underground. Initial examinations in 1964 and 1965 by Dr. Rogers and Dr. Domm indicated pneumoconiosis but advised him he could continue working. By 1967, his condition severely deteriorated, making him unable to breathe adequately or continue his work. The court found that his occupational disease arose out of his employment and that his claim was not barred by the one-year statute of limitations. The judge ruled that the plaintiff did not have proper notice of a disabling condition until 1967, despite earlier diagnoses of nodules. Consequently, the court fixed his permanent partial disability at 85%.

Occupational DiseaseSilicosisPneumoconiosisCoal Mining InjuryStatute of Limitations DefenseDisability AssessmentMedical Expert TestimonyPulmonary Function TestKnowledge of DisabilityTennessee Law
References
8
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Gibson v. Consolidation Coal Co.

Jessie Gibson, a coal miner with 47 years of experience, was found totally disabled by coal worker’s pneumoconiosis by the trial judge, receiving benefits under the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969. The court affirmed this decision, emphasizing the legislative intent to adopt federal standards for pneumoconiosis cases in Tennessee. The ruling highlighted the use of a rebuttable presumption for miners with over 15 years experience and a totally disabling respiratory impairment, even when X-rays are negative. Despite conflicting medical opinions, the court found material evidence supported the trial judge's decision, considering the totality of the claimant's medical history and testimony.

Workmen's CompensationCoal Worker's PneumoconiosisBlack Lung DiseaseOccupational DiseaseTotal DisabilityFederal Coal Mine Health and Safety ActBlack Lung Benefits ActMedical EvidenceRebuttable PresumptionRespiratory Impairment
References
7
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Consolidated Coal Co. v. Bray

The Supreme Court of Tennessee affirmed an award of total permanent disability benefits to an employee suffering from coal worker’s pneumoconiosis, despite the employer's appeal. The employer contested the causal link between the disability and pneumoconiosis, suggesting a heart condition, and cited errors in evidence handling. The Court found substantial and material evidence, particularly Dr. Domm's expert testimony, sufficient to support the trial court's finding that the lung disease alone caused total permanent disability. Furthermore, the Court upheld the exclusion of federal black lung benefit application data as substantive proof and deemed the employee's testimony about Dr. Wender's statements admissible given the employer's prior cross-examination.

workmen's compensationtotal permanent disabilitycoal worker's pneumoconiosislung diseasemedical evidenceexpert testimonyDr. Dommhearsayevidence exclusionappellate review
References
3
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Caudill v. Consolidation Coal Co.

This workers' compensation appeal involves consolidated claims for coal miner’s pneumoconiosis and back injuries. The trial court initially awarded 100% total permanent disability for pneumoconiosis and 65% permanent partial disability for back injuries, dismissing the Second Injury Fund and allowing the employer to offset benefits. The Special Workers’ Compensation Appeals Panel affirmed the dismissal of the Second Injury Fund and the employer's liability for all disability benefits. However, the Panel reversed the trial court’s decision regarding the set off of back injury disability payments against black lung payments, citing statutory prohibitions against relieving employers of their obligations. The case was remanded for further orders consistent with the Panel's opinion.

PneumoconiosisBlack Lung DiseaseBack InjuryTotal Permanent DisabilityPermanent Partial DisabilitySecond Injury FundEmployer LiabilitySet Off BenefitsOccupational DiseaseAppeals Panel
References
6
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision

Hensley v. Consolidation Coal Co.

This worker's compensation case concerns a plaintiff seeking benefits for pulmonary disability allegedly caused by coal worker’s pneumoconiosis. The chancellor dismissed the claim, finding insufficient proof that the disability was primarily due to pneumoconiosis and that the plaintiff's coal mine employment did not meet the 15-year threshold for a rebuttable presumption under federal law. On appeal, the plaintiff contended that medical evidence and federal regulations supported his claim and that the presumption should apply despite the chancellor's findings on his work history. The appellate court, bound by the material evidence rule, affirmed the trial court's judgment, noting a pulmonary specialist, Dr. Arnold R. Hudson, Jr., attributed the plaintiff's disability to other factors like smoking, asthma, and obesity, rather than coal dust exposure.

Worker's CompensationPulmonary DisabilityCoal Worker's PneumoconiosisBlack Lung DiseaseMaterial Evidence RuleCausation (Medical)Rebuttable PresumptionFederal Coal Mine Health and Safety ActEmphysemaBronchial Asthma
References
3
Case No. MISSING
Regular Panel Decision
Dec 01, 1978

Boney v. Gouverneur Talc Co.

The appellants, an employer and its insurance carrier, appealed a Workers’ Compensation Board decision, contending that the record lacked sufficient evidence to establish a definitive causal link between the decedent’s lung cancer (carcinomatosis) and his harmful mineral exposure, which admittedly caused pneumoconiosis. The Board had found, based on Mr. Kitts' testimony, that talcosis samples contained 2%-60% asbestos and, supported by Dr. Miller's testimony, that pneumoconiosis predisposes to lung cancer, and Dr. Maxon's testimony, that a definite relationship exists between asbestosis and lung cancer. Consequently, the Board concluded that the decedent's death from occupational talcosis was causally related to his compensable condition. The appellate court found that the record contained substantial evidence supporting the award of death benefits and therefore affirmed the Board's decision, with costs awarded against the employer and its insurance carrier.

Lung CancerPneumoconiosisAsbestosisOccupational DiseaseDeath BenefitsCausal RelationshipMedical TestimonyWorkers' Compensation AppealMineral ExposureTalcosis
References
1
Showing 1-10 of 40 results

Ready to streamline your practice?

Apply these legal strategies instantly. CompFox helps you find decisions, analyze reports, and draft pleadings in minutes.

CompFox Logo

The AI standard for workers' compensation professionals. Faster research, deeper analysis, better outcomes.

Product

  • Platform
  • Workflow
  • Features
  • Pricing

Solutions

  • Defense Firms
  • Applicants' Attorneys
  • Insurance carriers
  • Medical Providers

Company

  • About
  • Insights
  • Case Law

Legal

  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Trust
  • Cookies
  • Subscription

© 2026 CompFox Inc. All rights reserved.

Systems Operational